Friday, 26 April 2013

Amnesty International Australia

Written by  Mara Moustafine

-2006 Iraq Country Information

Saddam Hussein's regime collapsed in April 2003 three weeks into a US-led campaign. Restoring civil order and creating a new political system have proved problematic for the occupying forces and continues to present significant challenges. Attempting to defuse religious and ethnic tensions is an immensely difficult task. The implementation of the Repatriation and Reintegration Plan will be substantially hindered while this instability continues. After twelve years of sanctions, the difficulties being faced whilst attempting to rebuild the country both economically and politically are inevitable. Iraq is currently experiencing a tumultuous political, religious and social environment, where the Coalition has failed to restore order. The lawlessness of Iraq has become undeniable.

Several months after the downfall of Saddam Hussein, an interim governing council (IGC) was created. The US-led Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA) in Iraq is headed by American career diplomat Paul Bremer. Mr Bremer is the top civilian official in Iraq. He is responsible for overseeing the reconstruction and the political transformation of the country. He has said that his priorities are to restore law and order and to stimulate the moribund economy.
The interim governing council held its first meeting in July 2003. Its 25 members were appointed by Mr Bremer. They broadly reflect Iraq's ethnic make-up. The council can appoint ministers and pass the budget, but ultimate control of Iraq rests with the US administrator.
In November 2003 the council announced the idea that there will be a handover to an interim Iraqi government on 30 June, that Mr Bremer will then depart and that elections will be held for a transitional assembly by January next year. This will, in turn, draw up a permanent constitution and set elections by the end of 2005 for a fully-fledged Iraqi government.
Prior to the conflict, Amnesty International had warned that the fall of the Iraqi regime would create extreme disorder and human rights violations. It has become apparent that the operation to restore order in Iraq will take years not months. Today, the general atmosphere in Iraq is one that is unsafe and insecure, and Amnesty International has stressed that:
[i]t could be many months, if not years, before the situation in Iraq becomes sufficiently stable and secure to allow the safe and dignified return of refugees amid a respect for all human rights.
Patrick Basham, senior fellow with the Centre for Representative Government of the Cato Institute in Washington recently stated that:
the White House will be gravely disappointed with the result of its effort to establish a stable liberal democracy in Iraq, or any other nation home to a large population of Muslims or Arabs, at least in the short-to-medium term... Paradoxically, a more democratic Iraq may also be a repressive one. It is one thing to adopt formal democracy but quite another to attain stable democracy.

There are many problems which have arisen in post-war Iraq including: mines throughout the country; the destruction of infrastructure; looting; car-jackings; an increase in crime; lack of legal structure and law enforcement; destruction of important documents; lack of water, electricity and medical supplies; lack of a central government; a fragile ethnic and religious balance; the possibility that former regime followers have perpetuated tensions and instability following the loss of privileges previously awarded to them; and many wealthy people have been, or are being held for ransom. In addition, the incidents of recent months, where international organisations have been the targets of violence, have created a new set of issues.
It is a country which cannot be categorised as being safe or secure in its present climate. The prevalent problems within the country seem to be increasing and an effective way of curtailing them has not become apparent at this stage.
Crime and Legal Process
The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) has found the situation in Iraq to be "highly volatile,"
with a dangerous security environment in many parts of the country and a high incidence of violent crime.
Thirty thousand prisoners were released by Saddam Hussein in Iraq in October 2002 further increasing the country's crime rate. Crime rates in Iraq are much higher now than before the occupation. The incidence of looting, car-jacking, kidnap, rape and murder have all risen since the declared end of the war.
The policing situation in Iraq has been rendered almost ineffective due, for instance, to the following: its significantly decreased police force; the mass dismissal of management and personnel; the lack of administration and structure within the police force; loss of documents; loss of vehicles to use for investigations; lack of communications equipment; in-fighting and increased crime rates.
The US-led coalition has clearly failed to provide public security and it seems that guerrilla warfare has intensified in Iraq. Between August 2003 and the beginning of 2004 bomb attacks killed hundreds of people, whom included UN's chief envoy, Red Cross office members and hundreds of soldiers.
The UNHCR has recognised an absence of functioning legal and judicial structures in much of Iraq, and the complex situation related to land and property rights throughout the country. Given the loss of many documents, including the destruction of those relating to property title, this latter problem has been exacerbated.
After the violence in the central Iraqi town of Falluja at the end of March 2004, where Muslim leaders have condemned the mutilation of the bodies of four Americans killed in the town, the UNHCR remains very concerned about the volatility of the situation in Iraq as well as the dangers faced by people inside the country, nationals and foreigners alike. The Minister of Displacement and Migration, Mohammed J. Khodair, has specifically requested that countries should not encourage or force Iraqis to go back until the situation has improved, especially for refugees.
Gender Persecution
At the end of March 2003, an attempted assassination against the only female member in the Iraqi cabinet, Nisreen Mustafa al-Burwari took place, again highlighting the urgent need for security in Iraq. The attack was the second directed at a female political leader.
Violence against women and girls has sharply increased in Iraq compared to the time before the 2003 conflict began. Many women and girls live under constant fear of being harassed, beaten, abducted, raped or murdered.
At one police station that Human Rights Watch visited, Iraqi police officers said that prior to the war they typically received one rape complaint every three months but had seen several cases in the few weeks since they had been reopened after the war. Other police officers interviewed by Human Rights Watch said that the number of sexual assaults had increased dramatically following the war.
Women face arrest solely because the authorities seek their relatives or husbands. The wife and daughter of the former Vice Chairman of the Iraqi Revolutionary Council, Izzat Ibrahim al-Duri, were arrested in November last year. The CPA has acknowledged that they are detained, but they haven't said anything about their legal status or the reason for the detention. Amnesty International is concerned that the arrest may have been carried out in order to pressure Izzat Ibrahim al-Duri to surrender himself.
Many women have been abducted since the war ended. Out of thirty or so women and girls Human Rights Watch interviewed, virtually everyone cited fear of abduction and sexual violence as justification for not returning to or looking for work, holding children back from school, and in many case, preventing young women and girls from leaving the house.
Women and girls in Basra told Amnesty International that they do not dare go out alone anymore, for fear of rape, abduction and other violence. Parents are frightened to send their daughters to school and university. One school, which experienced the disappearance of a female student, saw attendance decrease from a total of 32 students to just 6, as girls stayed inside for fear of being abducted or sexually assaulted.
Many instances of sexual assaults and kidnap have not been reported, making it impossible to calculate accurate numbers. Many women do not report these crimes due to 'well-grounded fears of social ostracism, rejection by their families, and even physical violence' coupled with an inefficient police force, delayed or denied medical treatment and lack of forensic evidence.
The United Nations Resolution 1325, passed by the Security Council in 2000, reaffirms women's protection in armed conflict and post-conflict situations. It stresses the importance of women's participation in peace building and conflict resolutions. Equality and non-discrimination is a crucial part of eradicating violence against women.
Iraqi Islamism and the Persecution of Religious Minorities
In post-war Iraq, many Muslims are pursuing an Islamic state in Iraq more ardently than before, and this is inevitably at the expense of the religious minorities within the country, including Christians and Mandaeans, who represent 3% of the estimated population of 24 million.
A United Kingdom Home Office country report on Iraq stated that "Shia religious parties and militias have stepped into the vacuum caused by the fall of Saddam Hussein's regime." As a result, Iraqi minorities are concerned about religious freedom in the country following the war.
Even though the interim constitution that the Iraqi Governing Council (IGC) signed on March 8 guarantees freedom of religion, worship and expression, the Shi'i who were brutally repressed under Saddam Hussein's regime have become a force to be reckoned with and are calling for an Islamic Republic with all the accompanying attributes.
Dr E. Hunter states that if the country of Iraq survives as an entity, it will become an Islamic Republic and minority communities, including the Jews, Christians and Mandaeans, will have no voice.
In the summer of 2003, prompted by radical Iraqi cleric Moqtada Sadr, the Iaq's Medhi Army (MA) militia was created. Young men were recruited at offices near mosques to defend the Shia Muslim faith and their country in defiance of the US-led coalition's arms controls. Even though the militia has no more than a few thousand actual members, it continues to take on new members and to have access to guns. As the BBC's Paul Wood reports, Moqtada is believed to have the support of up to 15% of Iraq's Shia community, or just under 2.5 million people.
Due to the escalation of violence in Iraq, Amnesty International is concerned about the safety of religious minorities.

The Mandaeans (known also as Sabians in Arabic) are followers of John the Baptist. They fled east from the Jordan Valley in approximately A.D. 70 and settled in what is now Southern Iraq and South Western Iran. Since the Islamic conquest in the seventh century they have suffered savage persecution by Moslem groups. At present the Mandaean community is estimated to be approximately 50,000 to 60,000 in Iraq.

General Information
As indicated by Prof. J.J. Buckley – an internationally recognised specialist on the Mandaean religion - in her August 2003 report to Amnesty International,
[s]ince the March 2003 U.S. occupation of Iraq, the world community still lacks information on the Mandaeans, despite the considerable Iraq-coverage in the media... the Muslim violence against the
Mandaeans is escalating during the current conditions... The very life of the Mandaean community in Iraq is in grave danger.
According to the Sabian Mandaean Association, specific examples of Mandaean persecution in post war Iraq have been varied yet extreme, including murders, rapes, assaults, and robberies.
During the years of Saddam Hussein's regime, Mandaeans in Iraq were targeted by the Mukhabarat (secret police) for financial contributions, sometimes demanded at gunpoint, on pain of shooting their families.
In the present climate of unrest in Iraq, the situation of Mandaeans is extremely worrying and exacerbated, due to the breakdown of law and order.

Examples of Incidents which Characterise Everyday Life for Mandaeans in Iraq
The following are examples of incidents which characterise everyday life for Mandaeans in Iraq. The intensity of these acts varies and the consequences can be very severe.
As is the case for Mandaeans who live in Iran, Iraqi Mandaeans are considered unclean by Muslims, and encounter difficulties when performing such daily tasks as shopping. They are not allowed to touch a Muslim or work in the food industry as they are perceived to render unclean everything they touch. A Mandaean who accidentally touches an item may be confronted with the demand to buy the entire stock as it has been rendered 'unclean'.
In 2003, there have been several fatwas linking the Mandaeans with 'kaffirs' or 'star-worshippers' and as such, being considered unclean, Mandaeans are at the very least to be shunned. Consequently, Muslims may not eat in the company of Mandaeans, this discrimination extending to school-children.
Disruption of Mandaean family life: forced marriage and sexual assault
Prior to the war, Iraqi authorities attempted to break up Mandaean families with a particular focus on women and children, pressuring them to convert to Islam and pressuring women to marry Muslim men. This practice still appears to be occurring; however it is now instigated by some Muslims rather than by the authorities.
In her most recent report to Amnesty International, Prof. Buckley has stressed that "[f]orced divorces were common, in order to break up Mandaean families and to enforce Muslim marriages." The Mandaean Human Rights Committee has also documented that the Iranian authorities attempt to break up Mandaean families with a particular focus on women and children, pressuring them to convert to Islam and pressuring women to marry Muslim men. Regarding the sexual assault of Mandaean girls and women, several reports suggest that Islamic judges would hold that a Muslim male who raped a Mandaean female would be understood to have "purified" her. Accordingly, the Sabian Mandaean Association reports that Mandaean girls have been raped with impunity by Muslim men.
The abductions of young women are all too common in Iraq today and threaten all communities, especially Mandaeans. Dr E. Hunter agrees that there have been numerous cases where young girls have been abducted and 'married' to Muslims, which make them unable to retain their faith.
There has been at least one known case of a young man being abducted and forcibly circumcised to effect a 'conversion' to Islam. This action effectively removes a person from their family and faith since a Mandaean man may not be circumcised.
Forced conversions
Dr E. Hunter says reliable sources indicate that many Mandaeans have been converted to Islam, with estimates of approximately 90% in Falluja. Mandaeans are also exposed to those who give a violent interpretation of Islam, including the actions of Wahabi Islamists, as well as members of Ikhwan Al-Moslemin and Al-Daawa Al-Islamiyyah.
The situation regarding Mandaeans is worrying.
Medical Assistance
As in Iran, it is difficult for Mandaeans to receive medical assistance due to the view that they are unclean. If a Muslim practitioner treats a Mandaean, the doctor is believed to be rendered unclean and will not be able to treat Muslim patients.
Limitations to practicing the Mandaean Religion in Iraq
As indicated above, reports state that Mandaeans are sometimes forced against their will to convert to Islam.
If Mandaean children attend Government schools they must study the Islamic religion and cut their hair which is in direct contrast to the Mandaean mandate that forbids boys from cutting their hair and excludes priests from the priesthood if they cut their hair. To blend into Iraqi society, they wear similar clothing to Muslims, learn Muslim customs and Mandaean children are involuntarily being given Muslim names. This latter action also occured in order to adhere to a law passed by Saddam Hussein, requiring that all babies born in Iraq must be given an Arabic or Islamic name. This law does not seem to have been relaxed for Mandaeans at the present time.
A Mandaean priest, Ganzefra Fawzi Masboob, who has since emigrated from Iraq, was faced with jail if he did not give information on Mandaean families. He was barred by police from baptising in the Tigress River and was stoned by the public numerous times during these ceremonies.
Protection of Mandaeans
With the breakdown of order in Iraq, Muslims have appropriated property and other wealth belongings to Mandaeans. Mandaeans have also been killed because they are not Muslim. Recently, a Muslim student killed a Mandaean English teacher. When asked by the judge why he did so, the student replied that it was halal to kill the teacher because he was a Sabian.
Practically speaking, Mandaeans do not belong to any tribal groupings. Thus in cases of homicide, the families do not have the right to 'blood money' which is inherent otherwise. In the past, Mandaeans negotiated their protection with tribes, by paying considerable sums of money. However, in the disintegrated lawless environment of Iraq, tribes have not always maintained such protection, leaving the Mandaeans very vulnerable.

General Situation
A letter sent to the Sabian Mandaean Association, dated 3 June 2003 and written by Dr. Faezah al-Aziz, a doctor based in Baghdad, contained disturbing reports about the situation faced by Mandaeans in Iraq:
On the first days they murdered more than 30 men from our community in different areas of Baghdad and outside Baghdad. They were not satisfied with that, so they entered the homes of our community looting and plundering... repeated daily... they forbid any female from getting out unless she wears the Islamic garb... They entered the home of Sallam Ojiel and took great deal from it even his private car, and burned down his factory that cost him over US $1 million.
According to the letter, after he was informed of the plight of the Mandaeans, the American in charge of Baghdad, advised Dr Faezah al-Aziz that the Mandaeans should leave Baghdad. The letter was countersigned and witnessed by the Rev. Tarmidsa Ra'ed Gabashi, a Mandaean priest.
Dr Crangle, of the Department of Religion at the University of Sydney, has stressed that:
[s]ince the demise of the recent Iraqi regime, many Sabean Mandaeans have been murdered by various extremist Muslim groups and tribes, including the extremely fundamentalist religious Sunni and Sheaat groups and parties such as Al-Wahabin, Al-Daawa Al-Islamiah and Ikhwan Al-Moslemin.
The Sabian Mandaean Association has reported the following attacks by various sources:
1 Evidence of human rights violations in Basra:
• May 2003: Nezher Rashem Asker (Abu-Jihad) was threatened by Muslims to be forcibly converted to Islam with his family. Muslims sent him threatening letters, but eventually he paid a large bribe not to be forced to do so.
• June 2003: Ms Mariam Alwan was attacked by Muslims: they assaulted and abused her, and stole her valuables and foodstuffs.
• June 2003: Ms Saadeyah Dhedan (Al Yum Hassan) was abused, attacked and assaulted by Muslims who tried to convert her to Islam. Indeed, when she refused to convert, Muslims attacked her and stole her valuables.
• August 2003: Khalid Farhan Saif was killed by Muslims.
• September 2003: Nadeer Al-Kuhaily was confronted by Muslims for him to convert to Islam. Nadeer refused and as a result he was shot and seriously injured, bad enough to spend a month at the Basra Hospital. (His testimony would be good to have).
• October 2003: Raeed Hwaiel was in his house when Muslims threw two grenades into his house.
• November 2003: Ms Abrar Saaeed was kidnapped by Muslims and forcibly converted to Islam, together with her family.
2 Evidence of human rights violations in the rest of Iraq:
3 Bagdad:
• June 2003: Raaed Bassim Al-Gailany was abused and injured by Muslims.
• Mrs Nadhimah Khuttar Al-Gailany, an elderly Mandaean lady, was attacked by Muslims in the Al-Saydeyah district: Muslims stole all her money and valuables, and attempted to kidnap two of her daughter's girls in order to convert them to Islam.
• 18 August 2003: A Mandaean girl whose name is unknown was fleeing from Bagdad to Amman, but ended up captured by Muslims who raped her and killed her.
• September 2003: Jinan Bassim Tabit was kidnapped by Muslims.
• 18 October 2003: Ms Siham Rahim was raped and killed by Muslims.
• October 2003: Seaa Mehsen was killed by Muslims.
• November 2003: Abdullah Darwish was killed by Muslims.
• 15 December 2003: Munder Hason Maula was shot 26 times in his shop by Muslims, who usually inflict multiple gunshot wounds to non-vital organs to ensure that their non-Muslim victims die slowly and painfully.
• 20 December 2003: Rafid Al-Khamisy was confronted by Muslims, in front of a lot people in Hay Al-Shurtha suburb, and ordered to convert to Islam. When he refused, they killed him.
• December 2003: Yahia Al-Kimisy was killed by Muslims in Hay Al-Shurta suburb.
• Rahim Salim Al Aubaidy's daughter was kidnapped in 2003.
• Ms Fakhriah Khdaier, an elderly Mandaean lady, was killed in her bathroom by Muslims in 2003.
• Muhannad Salim Al-Maanawy was killed by Muslims in 2003.
4 Falluja:
• June 2003: Mrs Rabha Naaeem was kidnapped by Wahhabi Muslims, who forcibly converted her to Islam and married her to a Muslim.
• June 2003: Ms Fahima Fingan Al-Khimisy was kidnapped by Wahhabi Muslims, who forcibly converted her to Islam and married her to a Muslim.
5 Baaqubah City:
• August 2003: Yahya Mardan Aflog and his brother Ihsaan Aflog were killed by Muslims.
6 Ammarah City:
• June 2003: 19-year old Fadaa Saddam was killed by Muslims in front of his house in Al-Haifayya village.
7 Nasreyah:
• November 2003: Afen Abu-Farooq, an elderly Mandaean clergyman was killed by Muslims.
8 City unknown:
• May 2003: Sabbah Shahib Al-Bab Al-Khimisy was killed by Muslims in front of his family.
• September 2003: Bassim Muhey Al-Khamisy's young son was kidnapped by Muslims, but he was fortunately rescued and returned by the British forces.
• September 2003: Muwaed Al-Kuhas was attacked by Muslims, who took all his valuables.
-November 2003: Ms Layal Tamol was kidnapped by Muslims and forcibly converted to Islam.
Dr E. Hunter has reported cases of murder, extortion and persecution in the latter part of 2003 as well:
• Fadha Saddam (19 years old).
El-Halfayeh village, near Amara
• Sabah Shebib el-Bab (retired, with 3 or 4 children)
Baghdad, el-Jedidah
Killed - beaten to death in front of his family.
Female members of the family were sexually abused
. -Hassan al-Wan (jeweller)
Paid a ransom in exchange for his life.
Female members of the family were sexually abused
• Basim Mohai
Son kidnapped and 30 million dinar ransom demanded
• Nadhir al-Choleili
Requested to convert to Islam, but refused.
Shot in head and leg, critical condition in Basra hospital
2 other members of Choleili family killed.
While Amnesty International cannot confirm the cases mentioned in Dr Hunter's report, Amnesty International does however concur with her assessment of the broader persecution of the Mandaeans in Iraq, having recently sent a delegation to Southern Iraq.
Kidnapping Reported by Amnesty International
Amnesty International has reported the following incident involving a Mandaean man. On 16 June 2003, Samer Bassem Muhy, aged about 20, was kidnapped from his family's gold shop. His uncle told Amnesty International delegates in Basra, Iraq that:
a group of between four and six men, kefiyahs wrapped round them, got out of a grey pickup; they were holding Kalashnikovs... They took Samer away... They called us and said they wanted US $100,000.
The family negotiated to pay US $10,000. As of 23 June 2003, they were still trying to collect the money to pay the ransom and Samer had not been released.
Fears for the Future
The Sabian Mandaean Association fears genocide for the Mandaeans remaining in Iraq due to the control seized by the Muslims in a seemingly lawless society. This point is reiterated by Dr Edward F. Crangle, who believes that Mandaeans who return to Iraq may face extinction and that the current anarchic situation in Iraq provides Islamist groups and their tribes with easy opportunities to act out their savagery.
The supreme spiritual leader of the Mandaean community in Iraq, Elrehema Abdullah Najem Zahroun Alsabti who emigrated to the UK out of fear for his and his family's lives, now fears genocide for the small Mandaean population in Iraq. He stresses that, as a minority, it is difficult for them to receive recognition of their rights. He states that his concerns stem from the many deaths of Mandaeans in the business community, and the sexual assault of Mandaean women (an act which, it is claimed, is intended to force these women to join the Islamic religion). He says that the plight of the Mandaeans has been suppressed and that any external delegations to their community in Iraq have been accompanied by government officials who threatened them if they complained. The government monitored all places of worship. According to the spiritual leader, a warrant for his arrest, and death threats have been issued since he fled the country.
The Sabian Mandaean Association in Australia has been informed that the Mandaean community, unlike the other minority communities, had been excluded from all discussions with the occupying authorities regarding the future of Iraq.
In her report dated 04 April 2004, Dr E. Hunter, from the Cambridge University states:
'I am quite confident that the persecution and violence which has been levelled towards the Mandaeans as 'kaffirs' will certainly continue and result in their extinction'.

The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees sent the High Commissioner's Special Envoy to Iraq. Based on the research conducted, they found a dangerous environment where violent crimes were prevalent. There was lack of judicial structure and much of the country had a deficiency in food and other assistance for their survival.
Based on their research at that point, they called on governments to extend a deportation moratorium on forcible returns of rejected Iraqi asylum seekers, also requesting states to maintain the provision of temporary protection for Iraqis, as well as the suspension of decisions on asylum claims.
Since the bombing of the UN headquarters in Baghdad on August 19 2003, the UN has deemed the situation in Iraq too dangerous for UN employees to remain in Iraq. At the end of September the UN presence was one tenth of the number of international staff present in Iraq prior to the bomb.
Further, given the extent of the continued instability, in September 2003 UNHCR requested that Iran desist from repatriating Iraqi refugees, with Iran agreeing to the request.
The Minister of Displacement and Migration at the UNHCR, Mohammed J. Khodair, has specifically requested that countries should not encourage or force Iraqis to go back until the situation has improved, especially for refugees.

The situation in Iraq is volatile and uncertain. While political stability may be achievable in the future, the religious problems that have existed in this country for many centuries cannot be overcome with a change in government. The persecution of religious minorities is likely to continue. The Mandaeans, as one of these minorities, are at particular risk of facing persecution if returned to Iraq.
Amnesty International opposes the forcible return of any Iraqis to Iraq. Amnesty International believes that asylum seekers from Iraq, in particular those Iraqis belonging to the Mandaean religion, may be at serious risk if returned to Iraq.
For these reasons, Amnesty International asks that all the Iraqi Mandaean cases, including those on Nauru, not be forcibly returned to Iraq and be granted permanent visas.
Yours sincerely